printRussian workers in the 1917 revolution:
the subject of the history or cannon fodder?
Mironov B.N.
Dr. Sci. (Hist.), Prof., St. Petersburg State University, St. Petersburg, Russia mironov1942@yandex.ru
Mironov B.N. Russian workers in the 1917 revolution: the subject of the history or cannon fodder?. Sotsiologicheskie issledovaniya [Sociological Studies]. 2017. No 2. P. 24-35
According to the author, Russian workers before 1917 did not form a class and did not possess a proletarian socialist ideology. They took an active part in the revolutionary movement and in the overthrow of the monarchy, but not because of their revolutionary character, their organization, or their awareness. Main reason for their increased revolutionism was the fact that they were semiliterate, the most demographically disadvantaged, the most marginal, and the most frustrated and criminogenic social group of the Imperial Russian population, and they were prone for these reasons to radicalism, aggressiveness, deviation, and manipulation. The radicalism and aggressiveness of the proletariat was echoed in the Social-Democratic program, the most radical and aggressive of all the political programs. Simple and understandable slogans and skillful propaganda ensured the success of the Bolsheviks in the proletarian context, and their large-scale, skilled organizational work allowed them to mobilize the proletariat and direct its energy into the necessary channels – for use as cannon fodder for the revolution.
Akton E. (2014) Revolyutsiya i ee istoriki: “Kriticheskii slovar’” v kontekste [The revolution and its historians: “Critical dictionary” in the context]. In: Akton E., Rozenberg U.G., Chernyaev V. Yu. (eds). Kriticheskii slovar’ Russkoi revolyutsii. 1914–1921 gg. [A critical dictionary of the Russian revolution. 1914–1921]. St. Petersburg: Nestor-Istoriya, 2014: 22–34. (In Russ.).
Avilov B.V. (ed.). (1922) Statisticheskii ezhegodnik, 1918–1920 gg. [Statistical Yearbook 1918–1920]: in 2 issues. Moscow: 14-ya gos. tip. Issue 1, part 1. II. Fabrichno-zavodskaya promyshlennost’ v 1918 g. [Factory industry in 1918]. (In Russ.).
Bairau D. (1992) Yanus v laptyakh: krest’yane v russkoi revolyutsii 1905–1917 gg. [Janus in bast shoes: The peasants in the Russian revolution of 1905–1917 years]. Voprosy istorii [Issues of History]. No.1: 19–32. (In Russ.).
Bineman Ya.M. (ed.). (1930) Trud v SSSR, 1926–1930: spravochnik [Work in the USSR, 1926–1930: Reference-book]. Moscow: Izd-vo Plankhozgiz. (In Russ.).
Bol’shakova O.V. (2009) Russkaya revolyutsiya glazami trekh pokolenii amerikanskikh istorikov [The Russian revolution through the eyes of three generations of American historians]. In: Shevyrin V.M. (ed). 1917 god. Rossiya revolyutsionnaya [1917. The revolutionary Russia]. 2nd ed. Moscow: INION RAN, 2009: 6–32. (In Russ.).
Chernyaev V. Yu. (1994) Rabochii kontrol’ i al’ternativy ego razvitiya v 1917 g. [Workers’ control and alternatives for its development in 1917]. In: Potolov S.I. (ed.). Rabochie i rossiiskoe obshchestvo. Vtoraya polovina XIX – nachalo XX v. [The workers and the Russian society: The second half of the 19th –early 20th centuries]. St. Petersburg: Glagol”, 1994: 164– 177. (In Russ.).
Davies J.C. (1971) When Men Revolt and Why. New York: Free Press.
Figes O.A. (1998) People’s Tragedy: The Russian Revolution, 1891–1924. New York: Penguin Books.
Fogt G. (1990) Novye aspekty nemarksistskoi literatury ob Oktyabr’skoi revolyutsii [New aspects of non-Marxist literature about the October revolution]. In: Sakharov A.N. (ed.). Istoriya SSSR v sovremennoi zapadnoi nemarksistskoi istoriografii: Kriticheskii analiz [History of the Soviet Union in modern Western non-Marxist historiography: A critical analysis]. Moscow: Nauka: 24–46. (In Russ.).
Gladkov I.A. (ed.). (1976a) Istoriya sotsialisticheskoi ekonomiki SSSR [History of the socialist economy of the USSR]. 7 vols. Moscow: Nauka. Vol. 1. (In Russ.).
Gladkov I.A. (ed.). (1976b) Istoriya sotsialisticheskoi ekonomiki SSSR [History of the socialist economy of the USSR]. 7 vols. Moscow: Nauka. Vol. 2. (In Russ.).
Gor’kii M. (1989) Sobranie sochinenii [Works]. 8 vols. Moscow: Sovetskaya Rossiya. Vol. 5. (In Russ.).
Hook S. (1975) Revolution, Reform and Social Justice: Studies in the Theory and Practice of Marxism. New York: New York University Press.
Isupov V.A. (2000) Demograficheskie katastrofy i krizisy v Rossii v pervoi polovine XX veka [Demographic catastrophes and crises in Russia in the first half of the twentieth century]. Novosibirsk: Sibirskii khronograf. (In Russ.).
Kaminskii L.S. (1987) Smertnost’ i semeinoe sostoyanie naseleniya [Mortality and marital status of the population] in: Ryabushkin T.V. (ed.). Sovetskaya demografiya za 70 let: iz istorii nauki [Soviet demography for 70 years: history of science]. Moscow: Nauka: 229–238. (In Russ.).
Keep J. (1976) The Russian Revolution: A Study in Mass Mobilization. New York: W. W. Norton & Co.
Khromov S.S. (ed.). (1982) Rabochii klass Rossii, 1907—fevral’ 1917 g. [The working class of Russia, 1907—February 1917]. Moscow: Nauka. (In Russ.).
Kir’yanov Yu.I., Volin M.S. (eds). (1989) Rabochii klass Rossii ot zarozhdeniya do nachala XX v. [The working class of Russia from inception to the early 20th century]. 2nd ed. Moscow: Nauka. (In Russ.).
Latynina Yu. (1993) Sobstvennost’ est’ krazha? (Property is theft?). In: Isupov K., Savkin I. (eds). Russkaya filosofiya sobstvennosti: XVIII – XX vv. [Russian philosophy of property: the 18th –20th centuries] St. Petersburg: izd-vo “Ganza”: 427– 444. (In Russ.).
Laue Th.H. (1964) Why Lenin? Why Stalin? A Reappraisal of the Russian Revolution, 1900–1930. Philadelphia: J. B. Lippincott.
Lenin V.I. (1962) Polnoe sobranie sochinenii [Complete works]. 5th ed.: in 55 vols. Moscow: Politizdat. Vol. 31. (In Russ.).
Martynov E.I. (2003) Politika i strategiya [Policy and strategy]. Moscow: Finansovyi kontrol’. (In Russ.).
Masionis Dzh. (2004) Sotsiologiya (Sociology). 9th ed. St. Petersburg: Piter. (In Russ.).
McKean R.B. (1990) Petersburg between the Revolutions: Workers and Revolutionaries, June 1907-February 1917. New Haven and London: Yale University Press.
Mironov B.N. (2012) Blagosostoyanie naseleniya i revolyutsii v imperskoi Rossii: XVIII – nachalo XX v. [The well-Being of the population and the revolutions in Imperial Russia: the 18th – early 20th centuries]. 2nd ed. Moscow: Ves’ mir, 2012. (In Russ.).
Mironov B.N. (2013) Strasti po revolyutsii: Nravy v rossiiskoi istoriografii v vek informatsii [The passion for the revolution: Mores in the Russian historiography in the information age]. Moscow: Ves’ mir, 2013. (In Russ.).
Mironov B.N. (2014) Rossiiskaya imperiya: ot traditsii k modernu [Russian Empire: from tradition to modernity]: in 3 vols. St. Petersburg: Dm. Bulanin, Vol. 1. (In Russ.).
Mironov B.N. (2015a) – Mironov B. N. Rossiiskaya imperiya: ot traditsii k modernu [Russian Empire: from tradition to modernity]: in 3 vols. T. 2. St. Petersburg: Dm. Bulanin. Vol. 2. (In Russ.).
Mironov B.N. (2015b) – Mironov B. N. Rossiiskaya imperiya: ot traditsii k modernu [Russian Empire: from tradition to modernity]: in 3 vols. St. Petersburg: Dm. Bulanin. Vol. 3 (In Russ.).
Neuberger J. (1993) Hooliganism: Crime, Culture, and Power in St. Petersburg, 1900–1914. Berkeley: University of California Press. Epilogue.
Orchakova L. G. (2008) Anarkhisty v politicheskoi zhizni Rossii (1903–1928 gg.) [Anarchists in the political life of Russia (1903– 1928)]. Dis. … dokt. ist. nauk [Dr. Sci., Hist.]. Moscow: MGPU. (In Russ.).
Paleolog M. (1923) Tsarskaya Rossiya nakanune revolyutsii [Tsarist Russia before the revolution]. Moscow; Petrograd: Gosizdat. (In Russ.).
Perrie M. (1987) Review: The Russian Working Class, 1905–1917. Theory and Society. Vol. 16.May. No. 3: 431–446.
Piazhe Zh. (Piaget J.) (1986) Teoriya Piazhe [Piaget’s theory]. In: Istoriya zarubezhnoi psikhologii (30-e – 60-e gg. XX v.) [History of foreign psychology (the 30th – 60th years of 20th century)]. Moscow: Izd-vo Mosk. un-ta: 232–292. (In Russ.).
Potolov S.I. (ed.). (1997) Rabochie i intelligentsiya Rossii v epokhu reform i revolyutsii: 1861—fevral’ 1917 g. [Workers and intelligentsia in the epoch of reforms and revolutions: 1861—February 1917]. St. Petersburg: Blitz. (In Russ.).
Pushkareva I.M. (2007) Vozvrashchenie k zabytoi teme: Massovoe rabochee dvizhenie v nachale XX veka [A return to a forgotten theme: the mass labor movement in the early 20th century]. Otechestvennaya istoriya [Russian history]. No. 2: 101–120. (In Russ.).
Pushkareva I.M. (2015) Rabochee dvizhenie v Rossii v gody Pervoi mirovoi voiny (istoriograficheskie zametki) [The Labor movement in Russia during the First World War (historiographical notes)]. Rossiiskaya istoriya [Russian history]. No. 3: 90–105. (In Russ.).
Pushkareva I.M. (ed.). (2011) Trudovye konflikty i rabochee dvizhenie v Rossii na rubezhe XIX – XX vekov [Labor conflicts and workers ‘ movement in Russia at the turn of 19th –20th centuries]. St. Petersburg: Aleteiya. (In Russ.).
Ragsdale H. (2003) Comparative Historiography of the Social History of Revolutions: English, French, and Russian. Journal of the Historical Society. Vol. 3. Issue 3–4. June: 323–372.
Rozanov V.V. (2001) Apokalipsis nashego vremeni [The Apocalypse of our time]. Saint-Petersburg: Azbuka. (In Russ.).
Rozenberg U.G. (2014) Interpretiruya Russkuyu revolyutsiyu [Interpreting the Russian revolution]. In: E. Akton, U. G. Rozenberg, V. Yu. Chernyaev (eds.). Kriticheskii slovar’ Russkoi revolyutsii. 1914–1921 gg. [A critical dictionary of the Russian revolution. 1914–1921]. St. Petersburg: Nestor-Istoriya: 35–51. (In Russ.).
Smith S. (1994) Writing the History of the Russian Revolution after the Fall of Communism. Europe-Asia Studies. Vol. 46. No. 4: 563–578.
Sobolev G.L. (1979) Oktyabr’skaya revolyutsiya v amerikanskoi istoriografii, 1917–1970-e gody [The October revolution in American historiography, 1917–1970]. Leningrad: Nauka. (In Russ.).
Stepanov V.V. (ed.). (1906) Chislennost’ i sostav rabochikh v Rossii na osnovanii dannykh pervoi vseobshchei perepisi naseleniya Rossiiskoi imperii 1897 g. [The number and composition of workers in Russia on the basis of the first General census of the Russian Empire of 1897]. In 2 vols. Saint-Petersburg: N. L. Nyrkin. Vol. 1 (In Russ.).
Stepanov V.V. (ed.). Raspredelenie rabochikh i prislugi po gruppam zanyatii i po mestu rozhdeniya na osnovanii dannykh pervoi vseobshchei perepisi naseleniya Rossiiskoi imperii 28 yanvarya 1897 g. [The distribution of workers and servants by groups of occupations and place of birth on the basis of the first General census of the Russian Empire produced on 28 January 1897]. Saint-Petersburg: N. L. Nyrkin. (In Russ.).
Suny R.G. (1994) Revision and Retreat in the Historiography of 1917: Social History and Its Critics. Russian Review. Vol. 53. April: 165–182.
Troinitsky N. (ed.) (1905) Obshchii svod po imperii rezul’tatov razrabotki dannykh pervoi vseobshchei perepisi naseleniya, proizvedennoi 28 yanvarya 1897 g. [The total compendium of results of the first comprehensive census produced on 28 January 1897]. In 2 vols. St. Petersburg: N. L. Nyrkin. Vol. 1. (In Russ.).
Vishnevskii A.G. (ed.). Demograficheskaya modernizatsiya Rossii 1900–2000 [Demographic modernization of Russia 1900– 2000]. Moscow: Novoe izdatel’stvo, 2006. (In Russ.).
Vserossiiskaya perepis’ (1926) Vserossiiskaya promyshlennaya i professional’naya perepis’ 1918 g. [All-Russian industrial and occupational census of 1918]. In 2 issues. Fabrichno-zavodskaya promyshlennost’ v period 1913–1918 gg. [Factory industry during 1913–1918]. Moscow: TsSU. (In Russ.).
Zimbardo F., Lyaipe M. (2000) Sotsial’noe vliyanie [Social influence]. Saint-Petersburg: Piter.