printDo Public Opinion Polls actually Provide a Survey of Public Opinion?
Šubrt I.
Dr. Sci. (Philos.), Assoc. Prof., Head of the Department of Historical Sociology, Faculty of Humanities, Charles University, Prague, Czech Republic Jiri.Subrt@ff.cuni.cz
Šubrt I. Do Public Opinion Polls actually Provide a Survey of Public Opinion?. Sotsiologicheskie issledovaniya [Sociological Studies]. 2018. No 12. P. 56-62
Sociological debates about public opinion have to weigh up theoretical dilemmas. The first of these dilemmas concerns whether public opinion appeared only with the advent of modern society, or whether it was a phenomenon in other, earlier types of society. The second dilemma is associated with the opposites of «realistic» and «nominalistic» approaches. The third dilemma is the contradiction between «monistic» and «pluralistic» positions. However, if we proceed from the theory of public opinion to its survey, we find a surprising thing: all the mentioned theoretical dilemmas are irrelevant from the survey point of view. Researchers (pollsters) are basically satisfied with a concept of public opinion which can be described as «operational». According to this, public opinion is what is measured by polls of public opinion. The basic pitfall of the operational conception is that surveys which should capture and analyze public opinion can easily fit the purpose of their specific producer, as the method of surveying public opinion can be transformed into an instrument for shaping it.
Грушин Б.А. Мнения о мире и мир мнений: Проблемы методологии исследования общественного мнения. М.: Политиздат, 1967. [Grushin B.A. Opinions on the World and the World of Opinions: Problems of Methodology of Public Opinion Research. Moscow: Politizdat. (In Russ.)]
Гэллап Дж., Рей С.Ф. Пульс демократии. Как работают опросы общественного мнения. М.: ВЦИОМ, 2017. [Gallup G., Rae S.F. (2017) The Pulse of Democracy: the Public Opinion Poll and How It Works. Moscow: WCIOM. (In Russ.)]
Уледов А.К. Общественное мнение советского общества. М.: Соцэкгиз, 1963. [Uledov A.K. (1963) Public Opinion of Soviet Society. Moscow: Sotsekgiz. (In Russ.)]
Allport F.H. (1965) Toward a Science of Public Opinion. In: Katz D., Cartwright, D., Eldersveld S., McClung L.A. (eds) Public Opinion and Propaganda: A Book of Readings. New York: Holt, Rinehart and Winston: 51–61.
Bain R. (1970) Veřejnost. In: Studijní a informační materiály II. Praha: ÚVVM ČSAV: 19–20. (In Czech)
Bauer W. (1930) Die Öffentliche Meinung in der Weltgeschichte. Wildpark; Potsdam: Akademische Verlagsgesellschaft Athenaion. (In German)
Bláha A. (1946a) Veřejné mínění. Veřejné mínění. Vol. 1. No. 3: 2–3. (In Czech)
Bláha A. (1946b) Veřejné mínění. Veřejné mínění. Vol. 1. No. 4-5: 2–3. (In Czech)
Bourideu P. (1979) Public Opinion Does Not Exist. In: Matterlat A., Siegelaug S. (eds) Communication and Class Struggle. Vol. I: Capitalism, Imperialism. New York: International General: 124–130.
Bryce J. (1899) American Commonwealth. Vol. I–III. New York: The Macmillan Company.
Davison W.P. (1970) Veřejné mínění. In: Studijní a informační materiály II. Praha: ÚVVM ČSAV: 1–16. (In Czech)
Durkheim É. (1926). Pravidla sociologické methody. Praha: Orbis. (In Czech)
Filmer P., Phillipson M., Silverman D., Walsh D. (1975) Neue Richtungen in der soziologischen Theorie. Wien; Köln; Graz: Hermann Bölhaus Nachf. (In German)
Gallup G. (1948) Průvodce po výzkumu veřejné mínění. Praha: Orbis. (In Czech)
Gellner E. (2002) Nacionalismus. Brno: CDK. (In Czech)
Habermas J. (2000) Strukturální přeměna veřejnosti. Praha: Nakladatelství Filozofického ústavu AV ČR. (In Czech)
Le Bon G. (1994) Psychologie davu. Praha: KRA. (In Czech)
Lundberg G.A. (1939) Foundations of Sociology. New York: The Macmillan Company.
Mc Dougall W. (1921) The Group Mind: A Sketch of the Principles of Collective Psychology with Some Attempt to Apply Them to the Interpretation of National Life and Character. Cambridge: The University Press.
Monroe A.D. (1975) Public Opinion in America. New York: Dodd, Mead and Co.
Noelle-Neumann E. (1980) Die Schweigespirale: Öffentliche Meinung – Unsere soziale Haut. München: Piper. (In German)
Noelle-Neumann E. (1989) Öffentliche Meinung: Die Entdeckung der Schweigespirale. Frankfurt/Main; Berlin: Ullstein. (In German)
Ogle M.B. jr. (1950) Public Opinion and Political Dynamics. Boston: Houghton Mifflin Co.
Tarde G. (1901) L'Opinion et la foule. Paris: Félic Alcan, Éditeur. (In Fr.)
Tönnies F. (1922) Kritik der öffentlichen Meinung. Berlin: Julius Springer. (In German)